Science is abused in a lot of Hollywood flick and TV , but perhaps none worse than neuroscience . movie get it all wrong , from mental illness and brainiac harm , to psychotropic drugs , memory , and even how neuroscientists work . Here are twelve movies and shows that do the worst caper represent the realism of the human brainpower .
1 . Limitless
This movie about a curiosity drug that can make you ultra - smart by help oneself you use “ 100 % of your brain ” is completely bogus . The idea that you only employ a small pct of your brain is a myth thathas been repeatedly expose — except in Hollywood , apparently . You practice 100 % of your brain every day , all day . So a drug that allowed you to use 100 % of your head would have absolutely no issue on you whatsoever .
2 . Side Effects
Where to start with this movie about a cleaning woman who takes anti - depressants and run on a shoot down spree ? Pretty much everything about it is amiss , start with the musical theme that a psychiatrist is still able-bodied to continue treating this woman , even after she ’s sued him for prescribing the drug . Second , anti - downer almost never make furiousness . And in the end , one segment of the film relies on the idea that placebos ca n’t have exactly the same outcome that drugs do , which simply is n’t the case .
3 . origination
You might think the least scientific part of this mind - muck up plastic film would be the dream - invading engineering , which our characters use to slip melodic theme from the log Z’s minds of their targets . But in fact , the main problem is that our brains simply could n’t concoct dreaming that are as elaborate and detailed as what we see in the movie .
As the Telegraph’sTom Chivers lay it :
Your head is not a 3-D modelling entourage . It can construct simple models , but if you , for example , seek to rotate a 3D look-alike in your mind , you’re able to only do a very canonical job . It could n’t build , for good example , a realistic model of a five - storey building terminated with plumbing and realistic shattering glass . Even if you could , it is daft to call up that , as you go to catch some Z’s , your mind would meticulously build up a huge , accurate world , and then have it running in the background while your dream - ego wanders off .
Basically , it would be far too energy - intensive for our brains to create dreaming this detailed . On top of that , it would make no evolutionary sense for our brains to do that anyway — we simply do n’t need to devote that much brainpower to dreams .
4 . Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless brain
In this movie , our lovelorn hero goes to a clinic to erase the memories of his ex - girl . The idea of using technology to erase memories is n’t all implausible . But given everything we know about how the brain puzzle out , you ca n’t selectively erase memories .
But the movie is n’t whole incorrect about how memory work . As the neuroscientist who goes byNeurocriticput it to io9 :
One incident in Eternal Sunshine is gently implicative of how memories might actually be hive away . It was after Joel had his memories of Clementine erase , and he could n’t think who Huckleberry Hound was . He had affiliate the sketch character and the birdsong “ Darling Clementine ” with her . That resembles a semantic meshwork , where an overlapping meshwork of nerve cell and synapses encrypt different but semantically related things .
5 . 50 First Dates
There are dozens of movies about eldritch memory glitch , but 50 First Dates is a honest exemplification of how wrong things can get . In it , Drew Barrymore has had an chance event which gives her a fake sort of amnesia , called “ Goldfield ’s Syndrome , ” which causes her to memory to reset to the sidereal day of her accident every day . ( Cue wild-eyed first day of the month shenanigans . ) It is possible for masses to suffer amnesia , and even lose most of their retentivity , after a oral sex wound . But nothing would do you to re - lose those memories again every dark .
The way amnesia from an injury commonly work is more like the movie Memento , where the main eccentric has marvellous trouble imprint newfangled memory . In world , amnesia from injury more often read that form — you do n’t lose your past ; you drop off your present .
6 . walk beat
One of the way that representations of neuroscience can run out is in the way the science itself is draw . magnetic resonance imaging imagers ( and passably much any other brain imaging twist ) apparently have magical powers to happen upon pretty much anything . We could beat up on the show House for this for about a 100 , but instead have ’s zero in on a truly terrible offender : there ’s an episode of The Walking Dead where we see an MRI scanner appears to display activeness in individual neurons , which are turning black as each part of the brainpower is zombified . In reality , MRI digital scanner show regions of the brain and would never be capable to show you activity in specific cell — permit alone show them modify colouring material or mutating in material clip .
7 . doll’s house
In this series , a mystic corporation can remove people ’s personality , hive away them on computers , and then download raw personality into the blank “ doll ” nous of our heroes .
No . You ca n’t do any of these thing . As the folk atStanford ’s Neuroblogput it , “ We can scarcely delete a soul personality , much less load a Modern one , if we do n’t know what engender personalities and witting view in the first place . ”
8 . Star Trek : TNG : “ The Game ”
A common theme in bad neuroscience stories is a technology or drug that can cause braingasms , or the “ ultimate pleasure , ” usually for the function of judgment ascendence . In the notorious Star Trek episode “ The Game , ” an evil group takes over the Enterprise by give everybody a videogame that shoot pleasure beams into masses ’s eyes and makes them all consist around moaning in ecstasy . ( Except Wesley , who saves the day . ) But according to neuroscientist , there ’s really no evidence that something like this would be possible . Theclosest examplemight bea tiny smattering of people who have become addicted to “ self stimulating”with brain implants used for alleviating symptoms of Parkinson ’s disease . But there is no grounds that this could lead to psyche ascendance .
https://gizmodo.com/the-curious-case-of-a-woman-addicted-to-her-brain-impla-5402584
9 . Source Code
The problems with this movie are exchangeable to those we understand in Inception , but magnified a hundredfold . Our hero sandwich ’s psyche is throw into that of a man who is about to perish on a wagon train — and he ’s able to use that man ’s nous to search constituent of the train and human race around him that the world himself never saw in life . There ’s a bit of softheaded timey - wimey here that ’s used to justify what ’s go on . But the fact is , you could n’t cheer an integral world from one person ’s case-by-case retention .
10 . Bourne Identity
Based on what we see with 50 First Dates , we know that amnesia rarely works the way it does in this famous serial about a super - agent who has lost his memory of who he was and what his missions entailed . You ca n’t bury your entire identity and awaken up with all your previous ninja acquirement inviolate . More likely if you ’d stick out from an unbelievably traumatic brain injury , you ’d have a damaged short - term memory .
11 . Fight Club
In Fight Club , a man acquire dissociative identity disorder passably arbitrarily as an grownup , and engender a doubling of himself . First of all , this is not usually how this sort of psychological disorder usually develops — in general , personality schism happen during childhood , often as a reaction to incredible psychological trauma . But the material kicker is that usually alter - self-importance are broadly not vehement . Indeed , alters often bear difficult or traumatic memory for the person who suffers from the disorder . So these alters are n’t crimson , but violate .
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IxeroqZSuo
12 . Videodrome
In this classic eighties David Cronenberg movie , a mathematical group of malefic scientists are send a radio beam into the brains of masses who watch violent pornography on an underground cable epithelial duct . This beam causes people to hallucinate and become radical - violent ( it also causes a spicy sex tantrum with Debbie Harry , of course ) . mental capacity wrong to the head-on cerebral cortex could actually get all these symptoms — hallucinations , and crimson , impulsive conduct . So you could imagine some kind of weapon that could cause harm to the frontal cerebral mantle and lead in Debbie Harry want to have kinky sex activity with James Woods . But that beam could not descend out of your television set .
Bonus Weird Counter - Example !
0 . Avatar
waitress , what ? How can Avatar have any variety of neuroscientific realism ? When our hero sandwich punch his neuro - ponytail into the brain of his flying steed , he ’s able to control it with his mind . Here we are seeing something that has actually been done ( more crudely ) in labs already . A recent experiment offer evidence that a human could contain the apparent motion of a rat ’s tailby link the human and rat brains via computing machine . So yes , one mean solar day , you might be ascertain a flying steed on a remote moon using only the power of thought . Well , maybe you ’ll just be controlling a puke in a laboratory . But still .
https://gizmodo.com/with-this-gadget-you-can-control-a-rat-using-the-power-968915580
That also intend thatthere ’s a puff of realism to the “ Drift”that relate two human minds together to check a elephantine automaton in Pacific Rim , too .
Many thanks to Neuroskeptic , Neurocritic , and Maia Szalavitz for assist with this article .
NeuroscienceScience
Daily Newsletter
Get the unspoiled technical school , science , and acculturation news in your inbox daily .
tidings from the time to come , deport to your nowadays .
You May Also Like
